DISSOCIATION OR SPIRITUAL AWAKENING? – WHEN THE DIFFERENCE IS NOT ALWAYS EASY TO SEE
There are experiences that can be difficult to understand when we begin exploring a more spiritual dimension of life. We may experience the familiar sense of being a separate self beginning to dissolve. The body may feel distant, thoughts may lose their usual significance, or we may no longer feel connected to the person we have always understood ourselves to be.
For some, this is part of a spiritual awakening. For others, it may be an expression of dissociation. And sometimes it is not that simple, because the two processes can overlap.
This is an area where I believe it is particularly important to pay attention. Not least because the experiences can look very similar on the surface, while having quite different causes and consequences.
WHEN THE SENSE OF SELF BEGINS TO DISAPPEAR
Both dissociation and spiritual awakening can involve a change in our experience of the self.
We may feel detached from our thoughts and emotions. The body can seem unfamiliar, and our usual sense of being a separate individual may change. Some describe it as being a witness to life rather than the person actually living it.
In spiritual traditions, such experiences are often described as a dissolution of the ego or a realisation that we are not identical to our thoughts or our personal history.
Psychology uses different terms to describe some of these same experiences. In dissociation, there can be a sense of distance from the body, emotions, surroundings or one’s own identity. We may feel like an observer of our own life, or as though the world is somehow unreal.
This can manifest as feeling outside the body, observing ourselves from a distance, or experiencing our surroundings as distant or unreal.
Interestingly, the descriptions of these experiences can sometimes be almost identical.
But the similarity of the experience does not necessarily tell us what lies behind it.
THE CRUCIAL DIFFERENCE
One important distinction concerns what happens to our connection with ourselves and the world around us.
Dissociation is often a protective response. When something becomes overwhelming, the nervous system may respond by reducing our contact with the body, emotions and surroundings. It can be a way of coping with experiences we have not been able to process or integrate.
Dissociation is not necessarily dramatic. It can be quite subtle. We may go to work, maintain relationships and function outwardly, while inwardly experiencing a considerable distance from ourselves.
During a spiritual awakening, our relationship with our usual sense of identity can also change. But this does not necessarily involve a withdrawal from life. Rather, it may involve a greater openness to what is, and a loosening of our attachment to the thoughts, beliefs and identities we previously took for granted.
We may experience a deeper sense of connection with life, greater spaciousness and a sense of freedom from our usual mental patterns.
This does not mean that spiritual awakening is always pleasant. It can involve anxiety, grief, confusion and periods of considerable instability. But there is a difference between having our usual sense of identity challenged and actually losing contact with ourselves.
And this difference is not always easy to recognise.
WHEN SPIRITUAL EXPERIENCES BECOME A WAY OF AVOIDING OURSELVES
One thing I believe is important to be aware of is that spiritual experiences can also become a way of moving away from psychological difficulties.
This can happen, for example, when we struggle to be with our emotions, our bodies or our relationships. Meditation and the experience of being pure awareness can create a feeling of freedom from things that are otherwise difficult to face.
But sometimes what we experience is not freedom. It may be a form of avoidance.
We may learn to observe our emotions from a distance instead of actually feeling them. We may use the idea that the ego does not exist to avoid looking at our own patterns, needs and boundaries.
This does not mean that the spiritual insight is false. But neither does it mean that the psychological aspects have been integrated.
A profound spiritual experience can exist alongside unresolved trauma, attachment patterns and emotional defences.
Insight is not the same as integration.
HOW CAN WE DISTINGUISH BETWEEN THE TWO IN PRACTICE?
There is no simple test that can determine whether an experience is an expression of dissociation or spiritual awakening. We need to look at the broader context rather than the experience itself.
However, there are some questions that can be useful to explore.
1. Is there connection or distance?
When you experience a sense of freedom from your usual identity, is there also a feeling of presence and connection with your body and surroundings?
Or is there more of a feeling of being distant, disconnected or not fully present?
A spiritual experience can involve a changed perception of the body and the self, but this is not the same as losing the ability to be present in your own life.
2. What happens to your emotions?
Is there more room to experience emotions, including the uncomfortable ones? Can you be with grief, anger and vulnerability without immediately having to explain them away?
Or do your emotions become distant, inaccessible or almost disappear altogether?
Being less identified with your emotions is not the same as being disconnected from them.
3. Does your connection with other people improve or deteriorate?
A spiritual process can change our relationships with others. Old relationships may lose their significance, and some of our values may change.
But over time, greater integration will often show itself through an increased capacity for closeness, empathy and honesty.
If, on the other hand, you become increasingly isolated, find it difficult to feel connected to others or experience a growing indifference towards relationships, it is worth exploring what may be happening.
4. Can you move in and out of the experience?
Can you experience the altered state of consciousness while still being able to return to ordinary daily activities?
Can you work, make decisions, recognise your needs and deal with practical matters?
Or do you become increasingly absorbed in the experience, to the point where everyday functioning becomes difficult?
A spiritual experience does not have to be something we can control. But the ability to move between different states and maintain contact with everyday life is important.
5. What happens over time?
Does there gradually emerge a greater sense of calm, coherence and spaciousness? Or do you become increasingly anxious, confused and estranged from yourself and the world?
A spiritual process can be difficult and unpredictable, but it is important to pay attention to whether the overall development leads towards greater stability or increasing psychological distress.
WE CAN EXPERIENCE BOTH AT THE SAME TIME
I believe it is important not to turn this into a question of either-or.
A person can have a genuine spiritual experience while also experiencing dissociative responses. An experience of the dissolution of the usual sense of self, for example, can occur during a period when the nervous system is under considerable strain or when old traumatic experiences are being activated.
One does not exclude the other.
It is also possible for a spiritual process to bring psychological material to the surface that has previously been kept at a distance. This may include old emotions, bodily reactions or experiences from childhood that are now beginning to emerge.
In such situations, it can be difficult to distinguish between what is part of a spiritual opening and what requires psychological processing.
This is why it is important to be able to hold both perspectives.
We do not need to reduce a spiritual experience to psychology. But neither do we need to interpret every psychological reaction as a sign of spiritual development.
If you experience persistent feelings of unreality, significant sleep disturbances, severe confusion or a noticeable decline in your ability to function in everyday life, it is important to seek professional help. This applies even when the experiences themselves feel spiritual.
INTEGRATION ALSO MEANS FINDING OUR WAY BACK TO LIFE
For me, an important question is not only what we experience during a spiritual process, but also what happens to us afterwards.
Do we become more able to be human? Can we feel our bodies, experience our emotions, engage in relationships and take responsibility for our own lives?
It is easy to place too much emphasis on extraordinary experiences. On those moments when everything seems to open up and our usual experience of being a person with a particular identity disappears.
But perhaps what happens in ordinary situations is just as important. When we get angry, when someone disappoints us, when we need to set a boundary or when we face something we cannot control.
Spiritual insight does not automatically free us from our psychological patterns. And psychological difficulties do not necessarily mean that our spiritual experiences are invalid.
It is about being able to hold both.
In psychotherapy, we can work on reconnecting with the body, exploring emotional responses and old patterns, and developing greater stability. Not to remove the spiritual dimension, but to allow it to become part of a more integrated human life.
Because perhaps, in the end, it is not so interesting how far we can move away from our usual experience of ourselves.
What is also interesting is whether we can find our way back to life with a greater sense of freedom, presence and the ability to be with what is actually here.
WOULD YOU LIKE SUPPORT IN MAKING SENSE OF YOUR EXPERIENCES?
If you are going through a spiritual process that has become difficult to understand or navigate, it can be helpful to speak with a psychotherapist who understands both the psychological and spiritual dimensions of these experiences.
At Open Mind Therapy, I offer psychotherapy with a focus on spiritual awakening, Kundalini, dissociation and the integration of intense spiritual experiences.
You are welcome to explore my approach and book a free, no-obligation 15-minute introductory call.
Find out more at www.openmindtherapy.dk/en/
You don’t have to navigate these experiences alone.